Orlando Weekly Best of Orlando 2026 winner for Best Personal Injury Firm and Best Law Firm Overall, four years in a rowOrlando Weekly Best of Orlando 2026 winner for Best Personal Injury Firm and Best Law Firm Overall, four years in a row

What Is Negligent Entrustment in a Truck Accident Case?

Negligent entrustment is a legal concept that holds a truck owner responsible for allowing an unsafe or unqualified person to drive their vehicle. If that driver causes an accident through negligence, injured victims may file a negligent entrustment claim against the owner to seek compensation.

However, truck owners may deny responsibility by claiming they were unaware of the driver’s unsafe history or had no reason to question their qualifications. At Todd Miner Law, our attorneys examine driver qualification files, driving records, previous traffic violations, and company communications to challenge these claims. We use this evidence to show that the owner ignored warning signs before allowing the driver to operate the truck. Call 407-894-1480 for a free consultation.

Lawyer discusses a truck accident claim with client across office desk during legal consultation meeting.

When Does Negligent Entrustment Apply to Truck Accidents?

Negligent entrustment applies when a truck owner allows a driver to operate their vehicle despite knowing about safety risks that could lead to an accident. For example, a trucking company may assign a heavy-duty truck to someone who has repeatedly failed driving assessments or shown difficulty controlling large vehicles.

If that driver loses control and causes a crash, you may have grounds to pursue a negligent entrustment claim. However, the claim must establish that the vehicle owner knew of the driver’s incompetence and that the owner’s decision contributed to the accident. For instance, if the collision resulted from an unrelated mechanical failure, the driver’s lack of experience may not establish negligent entrustment.

Who Can Be Held Responsible for Entrusting a Company Vehicle?

Truck owners, trucking companies, employers, and vehicle lessees may face negligent entrustment claims. They can be held accountable if they allow an unsafe driver to operate a commercial truck. In these situations, liability depends on who authorized the driver to use the vehicle and knew or should have known about the safety risks.

Additionally, more than one party may share responsibility if several businesses control the truck or authorize its use. For example, a trucking company and a separate fleet operator may both participate in assigning vehicles to drivers. In such negligent entrustment cases, each party’s liability depends on its own involvement in the decision and knowledge of the driver’s safety risks.

Under Florida Statutes §768.81, courts generally assign each negligent party a percentage of fault based on their contribution to the accident. For instance, if a trucking company bears 70% of the fault and a fleet operator bears 30%, each generally pays its respective share of the damages. Therefore, if the total damages reach $100,000, the trucking company would pay $70,000, while the fleet vehicle operator would cover $30,000 of your payout.

What Makes a Commercial Truck Driver Unfit to Drive?

A commercial truck driver may be unfit to drive if they lack the required qualifications, fail to meet the medical fitness standards under 49 CFR §391.41, or violate serious safety rules. Reckless driving, multiple DUI citations, and repeated traffic violations may also indicate that the driver poses a risk to others.

Here are some other factors that may make a commercial truck driver unfit to drive:

  • Poor vehicle handling skills: Difficulty turning, braking, reversing, or controlling a fully loaded commercial truck.
  • Failure to pass required driving tests: Inability to demonstrate the knowledge or practical skills required for commercial driving duties.
  • Unsafe driving habits: Frequent tailgating, improper lane changes, and failure to maintain safe stopping distances.
  • Inadequate cargo securement knowledge: Lack of understanding of cargo restraints, load distribution, and proper securement procedures.
  • Poor hazard recognition: Inability to respond safely to reduced visibility, sharp curves, steep grades, or changing road conditions.
  • Lack of a valid driver’s license: An unlicensed driver who operates a commercial truck without the required CDL or vehicle-specific endorsements.

How Is Direct Negligence Different From Vicarious Liability?

Direct negligence holds a trucking company responsible for its own actions, such as allowing a reckless driver to operate a truck. In contrast, vicarious liability holds the company responsible for its employee’s negligent driving while on duty, even if the company itself did nothing wrong.

Here are some other differences between these two legal theories:

Direct NegligenceVicarious Liability
Requires evidence of the company’s own negligence and how it contributed to the accident.Requires proof of the driver’s negligence and a qualifying legal relationship with the company.
Can involve several company failures, such as a lack of proper training, poor supervision, or unsafe vehicle maintenance.Can arise from a single negligent act by the driver, such as speeding or running a red light.
The company can challenge the claim by showing it took reasonable precautions and did not breach its duty of care.The company can challenge the claim by showing the driver acted outside the scope of employment.

Can Violating FMCSA Rules Prove Trucking Company Negligence?

Yes, violations of Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) rules can help establish negligent entrustment. These violations may show that the company ignored safety requirements or warning signs about the driver’s competence. However, you must connect these violations to the accident.

The following FMCSA violations may help establish that a trucking company entrusted a vehicle to an unsafe driver:

  • Driver qualification violations (49 CFR Part 391): Allowing drivers to operate company vehicles without valid licenses, required medical certifications, or adequate driving qualifications.
  • Failure to check driving records (49 CFR §391.23): Failing to conduct required driving history inquiries that could reveal previous accidents, license suspensions, or serious traffic violations.
  • Drug and alcohol violations (49 CFR Part 382): Allowing a driver with unresolved disqualifying drug or alcohol violations to operate a commercial truck.
  • Failure to maintain qualification files (49 CFR §391.51): Missing required driver records that could help establish if the company checked the driver’s qualifications before permitting them to drive.

In the 2022 case Murray v. Britton, Case No. 6:22-cv-00861, the U.S. District Court in Orlando addressed a negligent entrustment claim against MC Trucking. The plaintiff alleged that the company allowed driver Britton to operate its truck despite his poor driving record. The plaintiff also claimed that MC Trucking failed to check his qualifications before allowing him to drive.

Additionally, the plaintiff alleged that Britton drove while fatigued and exceeded federal hours-of-service limits. MC Trucking requested dismissal of the negligent entrustment claim, arguing that the allegations lacked sufficient factual support.

However, on December 20, 2022, the court denied the company’s motion to dismiss. The judge found that the driver’s poor record and the company’s alleged failure to check his qualifications provided sufficient grounds to proceed with the claim.

Which Florida Laws Affect Negligent Entrustment Claims?

Florida recognizes negligent entrustment under common law, based on Section 390 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts. Under this law, the injured party must generally establish four legal elements to prove negligent entrustment. These include entrusting the truck to the driver, the driver’s incompetence, the owner’s knowledge of the risks, and the resulting injuries.

However, the ruling in Clooney v. Geeting, 352 So. 2d 1216 (Fla. 2d DCA 1977) places an important limitation on these claims. If a trucking company admits responsibility for its driver’s negligence, courts may dismiss a separate negligent entrustment claim. However, the court may allow the claim to proceed if it establishes grounds for additional liability, such as punitive damages.

Additionally, Florida follows the dangerous instrumentality doctrine, which can hold truck owners responsible for accidents caused by drivers who operate their vehicles with permission. Unlike negligent entrustment, this doctrine does not require proof that the owner knew about the driver’s unsafe history.

Does Commercial Truck Insurance Cover Company Negligence?

Yes, commercial truck liability insurance or broader corporate policies can cover the company’s negligence, including negligent entrustment. Under Florida Statutes §627.7415, commercial trucks must carry minimum liability insurance based on their gross vehicle weight, including:

  • 26,000 to under 35,000 pounds: $50,000 per occurrence.
  • 35,000 to under 44,000 pounds: $100,000 per occurrence.
  • 44,000 pounds or more: $300,000 per occurrence.

However, meeting these insurance requirements does not guarantee coverage for every negligent entrustment claim. The insurer must assess the company’s liability, the policy’s terms, and any applicable exclusions before determining coverage.

What Policy Exclusions Can Affect Insurance Coverage?

Commercial truck insurers may dispute negligent entrustment coverage when the accident involves an excluded driver, an uncovered vehicle, or intentional misconduct. However, these restrictions do not automatically eliminate coverage for the trucking company’s negligence.

Here is how these coverage restrictions may affect your negligent entrustment claim:

1. Excluded Drivers

Some commercial auto policies exclude specific drivers through written endorsements. If a trucking company allows an excluded driver to operate its truck, the insurer may deny coverage after an accident. In these cases, our Florida truck accident lawyers investigate whether the trucking company has an applicable MCS-90 endorsement. This endorsement requires the insurer to pay a qualifying judgment for injuries caused by the driver, despite the policy exclusion.

2. Uncovered Commercial Vehicles

An insurer may deny coverage if the trucking company assigns an unsafe driver to a truck outside its policy’s covered vehicles. For example, a company may lease an additional truck without securing coverage for it. If that driver causes an accident, the insurer may argue that the policy does not cover the vehicle. To prove coverage, our attorneys review insurance policies, vehicle schedules, and leasing agreements.

3. Intentional Injury Exclusions

Commercial auto policies may exclude coverage when an insured person deliberately causes an injury. For instance, if a truck owner intentionally directs a driver to hit another vehicle, the insurer may deny coverage. However, allowing someone with a history of reckless driving to operate a truck does not automatically qualify as intentional injury. Therefore, this exclusion may not apply to an ordinary negligent entrustment claim.

4. Commercial General Liability Exclusions

A trucking company may carry both commercial auto insurance and general liability insurance. Commercial auto insurance covers qualifying truck accidents, while general liability insurance typically excludes injuries caused by vehicle accidents.

In Choxom v. Bankers Insurance Co. (2004), an employee caused a vehicle accident, and the injured parties sought compensation under the company’s general liability policy. They claimed that the company’s failure to properly train the employee contributed to the commercial vehicle crash. However, the Florida appeals court upheld the insurer’s denial because the general liability policy excluded vehicle-related accidents.

If your truck accident claim has been denied due to a policy exclusion, consult our attorneys at Todd Miner Law. We can review your insurance policy, assess the reasons for denial, and help you challenge an improper coverage decision.

What Should You Do if a Trucking Company Denies Liability?

If a trucking company avoids liability for negligent entrustment, consult our personal injury lawyers at Todd Miner Law. We gather evidence, including driver qualification files, safety complaints, disciplinary records, and internal communications, to establish the company’s knowledge of driving risks.

However, trucking companies rarely provide these records voluntarily. Therefore, we use legal tools, including formal discovery requests, subpoenas, and depositions, to obtain relevant evidence. We also question company representatives under oath to establish what they knew about the driver’s safety risks.

Additionally, our attorneys take the following steps to challenge claim denials:

  • Check substance abuse records: We examine drug or alcohol test results, failed screenings, and return-to-duty records to determine if the company overlooked substance abuse risks.
  • Identify contradictions in company statements: Our lawyers compare the company’s explanation with driver records, witness statements, and internal reports to expose inconsistencies.
  • Challenge driver qualification claims: We examine licensing records, medical certifications, and required training documents to dispute claims that the driver met safety requirements.
  • Investigate prior warnings: We examine the driver’s accident history, traffic violations, and safety complaints to determine if the company ignored warning signs before the crash.

Infographic shows records proving truck owner knowledge, including messages, emails, assignments, reports, after crash scene.

Call Our Attorneys to Establish Trucking Company Negligence and Seek Fair Compensation!

In many truck accidents, the trucking company may also face liability, allowing you to seek compensation from the company in addition to the driver. However, establishing company negligence requires strong evidence linking its decisions to the crash.

At Todd Miner Law, our attorneys have over 30 years of extensive experience handling truck accident cases across Florida, including Tampa Bay, the Space Coast, North Florida, South Florida, Southwest Florida, and the Florida Panhandle. We gather key evidence, establish how the trucking company’s decisions contributed to the crash, and negotiate with insurers to seek fair compensation.

If the insurer denies liability or refuses a fair settlement, we prepare your case for trial and use our courtroom experience to challenge the company’s defense. Call 407-894-1480 for a free consultation or visit our law firm at 915 Outer Road, Orlando, FL 32814 for trusted legal help.

FAQs

Can Negligent Entrustment Apply to Independent Contractors?

Yes, a trucking company can face negligent entrustment claims even if the driver was an independent contractor. For example, a company may provide a contractor with a truck despite records showing repeated license suspensions. In such cases, the contractor’s employment status does not prevent injured persons from pursuing a claim against the company.

Can Entrusting an Unsafe Driver Lead to Punitive Damages?

Yes, entrusting an unsafe driver with a truck can lead to punitive damages if the owner’s actions involve gross negligence or intentional misconduct. For example, a trucking company may face punitive damages if it knowingly allows an intoxicated driver to operate a truck despite serious safety warnings. However, the evidence must show that the company’s conduct met Florida’s strict legal standard under Florida Statutes §768.72.

Is Negligent Entrustment Different From Negligent Hiring?

Yes, negligent entrustment and negligent hiring are two different legal claims. Negligent entrustment focuses on allowing an unsafe driver to operate a truck despite known risks. In contrast, negligent hiring focuses on a trucking company’s failure to properly check a driver’s qualifications, driving history, and safety record before hiring them.

Does Negligent Entrustment Require Repeated Misconduct?

No, negligent entrustment does not require a driver to have a history of repeated misconduct. A single serious incident, such as reckless driving or driving under the influence, may establish that the driver posed a safety risk. However, you must show that the vehicle owner knew or should have known about that risk.

Can Negligent Entrustment Apply to Leased Commercial Vehicles?

Yes, negligent entrustment can apply to leased commercial vehicles. A trucking company that leases a truck may face liability if it knowingly permits an unqualified driver to use it. However, the lease agreement, the company’s control over the vehicle, and its knowledge of the driver’s safety risks affect responsibility.

FREE CASE REVIEW

Todd Minner BG
WRITTEN AND REVIEWED BY
Todd Minner BG
WRITTEN AND REVIEWED BY

Legal Disclaimer

The content on this blog is provided for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be legal advice. You should not rely on it as a substitute for speaking with a qualified attorney.

While we strive to ensure accuracy, some information may be outdated, incomplete, or no longer applicable. Legal outcomes vary based on individual circumstances, applicable laws, and jurisdiction.

Reading this blog does not establish an attorney-client relationship with Todd Miner Law®.

For personalized legal guidance, please contact Todd Miner Law® at 407-894-1480 or submit a request through our contact form to schedule a free consultation.

Call 407-894-1480
Add to Preferred Sources ★ Call 407-894-1480