Orlando Weekly Best of Orlando 2026 winner for Best Personal Injury Firm and Best Law Firm Overall, four years in a rowOrlando Weekly Best of Orlando 2026 winner for Best Personal Injury Firm and Best Law Firm Overall, four years in a row

What If You Were Partly at Fault in a Robotaxi Crash?

Florida’s modified comparative negligence rule lets you recover compensation after a self-driving car crash. That holds even when an insurance company says you were partly responsible. In other words, your award shrinks by your share of fault. You lose the claim only if a jury puts that share above 50% (Fla. Stat. 768.81).

Self-driving car accident claims often involve multiple parties. These include the fleet operator, the vehicle maker, and a software developer. Each one’s insurer may try to shift blame onto you. They may also point to how you left the car. They may cite where you stopped or what you did inside the cabin. However, the vehicle records and sensor data may show a different sequence of events.

At Todd Miner Law, our rideshare and Waymo accident lawyers help injured passengers and other road users. We fight fault allegations after autonomous vehicle crashes. We also handle claims involving any robotaxi or autonomous vehicle operator. Call 407-894-1480 to see if you have a valid claim.

Infographic shows robotaxi crash compensation percentages based on fault, including recovery limits under Florida law.

Can You Recover Damages After a Robotaxi Crash if You Share Fault?

Yes, Florida lets you recover compensation after a robotaxi crash even when you share some of the blame. In fact, self-driving car crashes follow the same comparative fault math as other collisions. Most states apply some form of comparative negligence, but the cutoff varies.

In Florida, HB 837 (2023) set that cutoff at 50%. Below it, your damages shrink by your share of fault. Above it, however, you recover nothing.

The table applies that rule to a $200,000 claim:

Your Share of FaultTotal DamagesWhat You RecoverResult
10%$200,000$180,000✔︎ Minor reduction
25%$200,000$150,000✔︎ Moderate reduction
40%$200,000$120,000◐ Large reduction
51%$200,000$0✖︎ Claim barred

Who Else Shares Fault in a Self-Driving Car Accident?

Several parties can share fault with you, and each one lowers the percentage an insurer can assign to you. A liability analysis of standard passenger vehicles turns on human error. In a self-driving car accident, there is no human driver to question, so insurers often turn to the passenger’s conduct instead.

Florida treats the automated driving system as the operator while it is engaged (Fla. Stat. 316.85), which shapes autonomous vehicle liability.

These complex cases with autonomous vehicles depend on records. One example is the 736 public-road automated-driving system crashes that IIHS counted from 2021 through 2024 (IIHS). Waymo launched its service to all riders in Orlando and Miami in April 2026.

As a result, a Waymo crash, or a crash involving any other self-driving vehicle, can create multiple potential defendants. The parties who may share fault and bear responsibility include:

  • The Fleet Operator Behind a Waymo Crash: The operating company deploys the self-driving technology. The fleet operator can be held responsible for missed hazards, unsafe routing, and skipped inspections.
  • Component Suppliers and the Vehicle Maker: A mechanical defect, such as a failed brake part, can cause a crash. So the vehicle manufacturer or a component supplier can be held responsible when a specific part caused the failure.
  • Software Developers: A software error in a self-driving system can make the vehicle misjudge a lane, a stop, or a pedestrian. As a result, that error can implicate the software developer alongside the operator.
  • A Human Driver or Safety Driver: If the crash involved a second vehicle and a human driver caused it, Florida divides fault among everyone responsible, including third-party drivers. A safety driver or other human operator in the vehicle can also shift accountability.

How Fault Is Split in Robotaxi Crashes in FL?

Most jurisdictions apply comparative negligence rules for shared liability in accidents, and Florida is one of them. When several parties share fault, Florida does not require one defendant to pay another defendant’s share. Under Fla. Stat. 768.81, the court enters judgment against each party based on that party’s own share of fault. So every defendant you identify adds to what your claim can reach.

Consider a $400,000 claim. A jury finds you 20% at fault, the robotaxi operator 50%, and a driver who ran a red light 30%:

PartyShare of FaultPays on $400,000Result
You20%$0✖︎ Your share, not recovered
Robotaxi operator50%$200,000✔︎ Recoverable
The driver who ran the light30%$120,000✔︎ Recoverable

So you collect $320,000 in total. If that driver carries too little insurance, however, the shortfall reduces your recovery. That is why UM coverage and a complete list of defendants matter. The split also shows what a disputed percentage costs. For example, moving 10 points of fault from the operator to you reduces the claim by $40,000.

The insurer’s initial breakdown of fault often omits parties who share the blame. To find out who else should be held responsible in your case, call our lawyers at 407-894-1480.

When Can a Robotaxi Company Be Held Liable?

A robotaxi company can be held liable through two separate legal routes: product liability and negligence. A claim to sue Waymo after a robotaxi crash can use both. However, your own fault does not, by itself, defeat either unless it exceeds 50%. The two routes rely on different proof, beginning with the vehicle itself.

1. Product Liability Claims

Product liability claims turn on proof that the vehicle was defective. First, lawyers sort defects into three types. A design defect affects every vehicle of a model. A manufacturing defect affects a single unit. A failure to warn leaves a known risk undisclosed.

For instance, a sensor failure, a software error, or a mechanical defect can support a claim. It may target the vehicle manufacturer, a supplier, or the company that deployed the system. Recall notices can also show a known problem. Waymo’s May 2026 recall of 3,791 vehicles, for example, addressed robotaxis that slowed but did not stop at flooded roads.

2. Negligence Claims

A negligence claim turns on proof that the fleet operator failed to use reasonable care. That duty covers deploying, supervising, and maintaining its fleet and its autonomous system. For example, weak safety standards, poor maintenance, and ignored warning signs can all contribute to it.

Important Note: Product liability and negligence claims can proceed in one personal injury lawsuit. So if a jury rejects one theory, the other can still support your recovery.

How Much Insurance Do Self-Driving Fleets Carry?

Florida requires autonomous vehicle operators running on-demand networks to carry at least $1 million in commercial insurance coverage (Fla. Stat. 627.749). In fact, the network holds that policy, not an individual driver.

For comparison, Nevada’s minimum is higher. Monitored autonomous vehicle providers must carry at least $1.5 million for bodily injury or property damage in any one accident (NRS 690B.470).

Insurance requirements for robotaxi companies in Florida set a $1 million minimum, but they do not limit what you can recover. Serious injuries can exceed it, so UM coverage on your own policy can cover the shortfall.

For example, UM coverage helped one of our clients. That client was riding as an Uber passenger when another driver rear-ended the vehicle. Our lawyers resolved the UM claim for $500,000.

Coverage usually applies in this order:

  1. PIP: Pays your initial bills regardless of fault.
  2. The company’s commercial policy: Pays for the vehicle’s share of fault.
  3. Your own UM coverage: Covers losses that the other policies do not pay.

The vehicle’s operational status also determines which policy provides primary coverage. If the automated driving system is engaged, the operator’s commercial insurance is the first place to look. If a human took manual control, a different policy may respond, so our lawyers confirm the driving mode first.

Which Fault Arguments Do Insurers Use on Passengers?

Once coverage is identified, the insurer’s next step is assigning you a share of fault. Insurers usually raise four arguments. They look at when and where you exited and where the car stopped. They also look at your seatbelt and cabin conduct, and what you said afterward.

Here is how each argument works and what evidence counters it.

1. Exiting Into Traffic

The most common claim is that you opened the door or stepped out at the wrong moment. In that case, the insurer will say your decision created the hazard, regardless of what the vehicle was doing. Door and sensor logs can also show when the car stopped, when the door unlocked, and when the crash occurred. As a result, that timeline often contradicts the adjuster’s summary.

2. Stopping Outside the Pickup Zone

First, operators direct passengers to set pickup and drop-off points. Suppose you changed the destination or asked the car to stop elsewhere. The insurer may then say you put the vehicle in the wrong place. Also, the app’s trip record shows what the car was instructed to do and who gave the instruction. A lawyer who secures it can then counter the argument.

3. Seatbelt and Cabin Conduct

Also, insurers may claim you were unbelted, distracted, or interfering with the vehicle. Florida does not treat a seatbelt violation as negligence by itself. But a court may consider it as evidence of comparative negligence (Fla. Stat. 316.614). However, in-cabin camera footage and belt-sensor data can confirm what you were doing at the time of the crash.

4. Statements to Support Chat and Social Media

In fact, anything you type to an operator’s support line or post online can be quoted back as an admission. For example, a casual line such as “I wasn’t looking” can be recast as proof of shared fault. Waymo’s insurer, or any other operator’s insurer, may also request a recorded statement soon after the crash. Therefore, decline a recorded statement until a lawyer reviews your account. Keep every other statement factual and brief.

Still, blame can be shifted back. In April 2025, a semi-truck drifted out of its lane and hit our client’s car, and the defense blamed her for the collision. Our attorneys used crash footage and expert witness testimony to establish the truck driver’s negligence, and the claim settled for $875,000.

Each argument rests on evidence, and the right evidence can defeat it. Speak with our lawyers. Before you respond to any insurer’s fault determination.

What Evidence Proves Fault After a Waymo Accident?

Robotaxi claims depend on autonomous vehicle liability, and liability depends on proof. The proof that lowers your share comes from two sources. One is the company’s technical evidence, and the other is your own records. In fact, a Waymo vehicle or any other robotaxi records telematics, lidar, radar, camera feeds, and software logs.

Autonomous crashes, therefore, generate far more data than a typical collision. A lawyer then combines both sources into a single timeline that addresses the insurer’s version.

The core evidence in a robotaxi crash includes:

  • Sensor logs and sensor data showing speed, braking, and what the system detected
  • In-cabin and exterior camera footage held by the operator
  • System logs and event data records from the moment of impact
  • Trip and routing records, including support chat transcripts
  • Your phone’s location history and any photos or videos you took afterward
  • Dashcam video and footage from nearby businesses or traffic cameras
  • Witness names and statements, including the human driver of any other vehicle, along with the police crash report

What a Reconstruction Expert Looks For

An accident reconstruction expert lines up the sensor data and other records second by second. Then the expert answers specific questions. For example:

  • When did the system first detect the hazard?
  • Did it brake or steer in time? Was the door locked or unlocked?
  • How fast was the car moving, and where was it relative to its assigned stop?

Each answer then supports or undercuts the share the insurer assigned to you. In addition, the timeline gives a jury something concrete to follow.

Why Evidence Preservation Cannot Wait

Robotaxi telemetry and video logs run on rolling retention cycles, allowing data to be overwritten. Witness memories can also fade within days after an accident. For that reason, a lawyer’s litigation hold demand asks the operating company to freeze those records. That has to happen before they are deleted. Meanwhile, if you were partially at fault in a crash with a robotaxi, follow standard accident protocols at the scene.

While that evidence is gathered, PIP is the first source of payment for your medical bills.

Important Note: Preserve vehicle data immediately after an autonomous vehicle accident. A written hold demand sent in the first days protects it.

Does Florida PIP Cover You if You Were Partly at Fault?

Yes, PIP pays regardless of fault after an autonomous vehicle crash. So a fault allegation does not cut off your early benefits. It generally covers 80% of medical expenses and 60% of lost wages, up to $10,000 combined. That applies when a provider finds an emergency medical condition. However, without that finding, medical benefits stop at $2,500 (Fla. Stat. 627.736).

The table below shows what PIP pays and what it leaves open:

What PIP CoversStatus
80% of reasonable medical bills✔︎ Covered
60% of lost wages✔︎ Covered
Benefits regardless of fault✔︎ Covered
Costs beyond the $10,000 limit✖︎ Not covered
Pain and suffering✖︎ Not covered
Property damage and vehicle damage✖︎ Not covered

For example, a single emergency visit with imaging and follow-up care can consume most of the $10,000. However, surgery exceeds it. Meanwhile, the claim against the operator or another at-fault party covers what PIP does not. That includes pain and suffering, as well as future medical treatment.

Important Note: Under Fla. Stat. 627.736, you must begin treatment with a licensed provider within 14 days of the crash. Otherwise, if you wait longer, your insurer may deny PIP benefits even if another party caused the crash.

What Compensation Can You Recover in a Robotaxi Accident?

A partly-at-fault passenger can seek compensation after a robotaxi crash. The damages you can recover fall into three groups. They are economic damages, non-economic damages, and, in rare cases, punitive damages. But PIP covers only early bills. Your share of fault then reduces each category before you collect.

1. Economic Damages

Economic damages cover losses with a price tag. These include medical expenses, future medical treatment, lost wages, reduced earning capacity, rehabilitation, and damaged property such as a phone. Medical records, pay stubs, and receipts prove each one.

2. Non-Economic Damages

In contrast, non-economic damages cover what a receipt cannot. After serious injuries, they can exceed the economic total. However, Florida’s no-fault law allows them only when the injury meets a threshold. Examples include a permanent injury, significant and permanent scarring, or significant and permanent loss of an important bodily function (Fla. Stat. 627.737). These damages may include:

  • Physical pain and suffering during recovery
  • Anxiety, emotional distress, and post-traumatic stress
  • Permanent scarring or disfigurement
  • Loss of enjoyment of daily life

3. Punitive Damages

Punitive damages require clear and convincing proof of gross negligence or intentional misconduct (Fla. Stat. 768.72). For example, a company that keeps deploying a vehicle after repeated, recorded failures of the same system could face such a claim.

White autonomous vehicle and silver sedan collide on sunny palm-lined city street with minor damage.

How Long Do You Have to File a Robotaxi Claim in FL?

Under state law, you have two years from the crash to sue for negligence in Florida (Fla. Stat. 95.11), a limit HB 837 cut from four years in 2023. Product liability can follow a different deadline, so confirm the deadline for your situation early. Our lawyers do that at the first consultation, because a missed deadline can end a claim, no matter how strong the evidence is.

In addition, waiting for the operator’s insurer to make a fair offer is a costly mistake. After all, strong car accident claims in Florida depend on early action. While you wait, records from a self-driving car accident get deleted. Meanwhile, witnesses move on, and the insurer’s story of fault hardens.

Most claims move through the four stages below:

1. Investigation and Evidence

First, we gather the company’s records, your medical files, and witness statements. Knowing what happens after a self-driving car accident helps you protect that evidence from the start.

We also send the litigation hold demand before routine deletion begins. In disputed-fault cases, for example, we have obtained crash footage. We have also retained experts to establish who caused the collision.

2. Demand to the Insurer

Once your treatment is complete, we send a demand letter. It documents faults, injuries, and losses.

The letter usually includes your medical records and bills, proof of lost income, and the vehicle and trip data. It also answers each fault argument the insurer has raised.

Timing matters because a demand sent before your treatment stabilizes cannot account for future care. We build the demand around evidence that addresses the insurer’s likely-fault arguments. That way, the insurer can see the evidence before it sets its position.

3. Negotiation

Then the insurer usually responds by disputing your share of fault or the extent of your injuries. We then answer with the car’s records and your medical proof.

For example, in December 2024, in Flagler County, the defense in a rear-end collision claim disputed our client’s injury. It questioned whether our client had a concussion or traumatic brain injury at all.

We pursued the case in court. Then we established that the injuries were real and caused by the collision, and we resolved it for $540,854.42.

4. Lawsuit, if Needed

Finally, if the insurer will not pay fairly, we file suit before the deadline expires. The case then moves into discovery and, if necessary, trial.

For example, in February 2026 in Orlando, the defense in a car accident claim disputed our client’s medical damages and wage loss.

Next, we filed suit, established the nature and extent of those damages, and resolved the claim for $910,000.

Get a Free Case Review from Our Robotaxi Accident Lawyers in Florida

Before you talk to anyone on the operator’s side, find out where your claim stands. Our robotaxi accident lawyers handle the investigation and insurance negotiations so you can focus on your recovery. We also represent people injured in rideshare, car, truck, motorcycle, and pedestrian accidents. So we understand how insurers shift blame onto injured people.

That understanding comes from the fault disputes we have handled. In those claims, the defense blamed our client for the crash. Others challenged the extent of the injuries or denied liability outright. The facts behind each outcome appear in our settlements and verdicts.

That track record has also drawn recognition from outside. Todd Miner Law holds an AV Preeminent rating from Martindale-Hubbell. In addition, Orlando Weekly’s Best of Orlando named the firm Best Personal Injury Firm and Best Law Firm Overall. That recognition ran for four years, 2023 through 2026. Clients have weighed in as well. More than 1,000 Google reviews average 4.9 out of 5 stars.

We represent people hurt in robotaxi crashes across Florida, including Orlando, Miami, and Tampa. Our office is at 915 Outer Rd, Orlando, FL 32814.

Ready to see where your claim stands? Call 407-894-1480 for a free consultation about how the insurer assigned fault. Also, bring your trip receipt, photos, and any correspondence with your insurer.

FAQs

Does Accepting the App’s Terms Waive Your Right to Sue?

No, not automatically. Many ride apps ask users to accept the terms of service. Some terms include arbitration clauses or other limits. Whether a clause binds you depends on three things. These are the exact terms you accepted, how the ride was booked, and who else is involved. For that reason, get them reviewed before any deadline passes.

Should You Accept the Operator’s First Settlement Offer?

No, an early offer usually arrives before your treatment ends, so it cannot account for future care. Settlement paperwork also typically includes a release that closes your claim for good. Therefore, have a lawyer review any offer from Waymo’s insurance company or any other operator’s insurer before you sign. Do the same before you give a recorded statement.

Does the Crash Report Decide Your Fault Percentage?

No, a crash report records an officer’s early impressions, not a legal finding. Instead, the fault is determined by the evidence in your claim or lawsuit. That includes trip data, camera footage, and witness accounts. In fact, insurers often revise their first assessment once the full record is on the table.

Can Your Spouse Claim Too?

Yes, in some cases. For instance, a spouse may bring a separate loss-of-consortium claim. It covers the loss of companionship and support when the injury is serious. Our lawyers also evaluate that claim alongside yours to ensure a spouse who can seek compensation is not overlooked.

Can Anyone Tell You What Your Claim Is Worth Right Away?

No, value depends on your injuries, how long treatment lasts, your lost income, and the share of fault that survives scrutiny. Anyone who quotes a number before your treatment stabilizes is guessing. So an early guess can lock you into a low settlement.

FREE CASE REVIEW

Todd Minner BG
WRITTEN AND REVIEWED BY
Todd Minner BG
WRITTEN AND REVIEWED BY

Legal Disclaimer

The content on this blog is provided for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be legal advice. You should not rely on it as a substitute for speaking with a qualified attorney.

While we strive to ensure accuracy, some information may be outdated, incomplete, or no longer applicable. Legal outcomes vary based on individual circumstances, applicable laws, and jurisdiction.

Reading this blog does not establish an attorney-client relationship with Todd Miner Law®.

For personalized legal guidance, please contact Todd Miner Law® at 407-894-1480 or submit a request through our contact form to schedule a free consultation.

Call 407-894-1480
Add to Preferred Sources ★ Call 407-894-1480