Hit-and-Run Case: How Long Does It Take to Settle?

A hit-and-run case typically settles within several months to over a year, depending on the severity of injuries, available evidence, and insurance negotiations. If a lawsuit is filed, resolving the case can take two years or even longer before reaching a settlement or trial verdict.

At Todd Miner Law, our car accident attorneys coordinate with law enforcement and investigate hit-and-run crashes to help identify the driver. If the driver cannot be found, we examine your uninsured motorist coverage and other available insurance options to pursue full compensation for your injuries and losses. Call us at 407-894-1480 for a free case review.

What’s the Average Timeline for Hit and Run Accident Settlements in Florida?

On average, a Florida hit-and-run accident claim takes about 6 to 18 months to settle. However, cases involving severe injuries, disputed liability, uninsured motorist claims, or lawsuits can take two years or longer to resolve. The process usually begins with reporting the crash to law enforcement and notifying your insurance company.

If the at-fault driver is identified, investigators gather evidence, such as police reports, witness statements, surveillance footage, and vehicle damage, to establish liability. If the driver cannot be located, your attorney will review your uninsured motorist (UM) coverage and any other available insurance policies.

Once your medical condition has stabilized and the full extent of your damages is known, your attorney prepares a demand package with strong evidence and requests compensation. Settlement negotiations then begin with the applicable insurance company. Many cases are resolved during this stage.

If the insurer disputes liability, denies insurance coverage, or refuses to make a reasonable settlement offer, your attorney may file a lawsuit. The litigation process includes discovery, depositions, expert evaluations, mediation, and, if necessary, a trial. While most cases settle before trial, filing a lawsuit can significantly extend the overall timeline.

Here’s an average timeline for each stage:

How Can Delayed Medical Treatment Affect the Settlement Process?

Delayed medical treatment can weaken your claim’s credibility, making it difficult to prove the severity and cause of your injuries. In such cases, insurance companies may argue that your injuries were not serious or resulted from something other than the crash. These disputes can lead to extended negotiations and make it difficult to recover full compensation.

To justify low settlement offers, insurers may also argue that your injuries worsened because you delayed treatment or failed to follow your doctor’s recommendations. In addition, gaps in your medical records can make it challenging to document injury progression. Resolving these disagreements may require additional medical assessments or opinions from medical professionals, extending the overall settlement timeline.

To avoid these issues, seek medical attention as soon as possible after a hit-and-run accident, even if your injuries seem minor. You must also continue attending follow-up appointments, follow your treatment plan, and keep records of all medical bills. Consistent medical documentation strengthens your claim and helps move the legal process forward.

How Does an Unknown Hit-and-Run Driver Affect the Settlement Timeline?

When the hit-and-run driver cannot be identified, the settlement process usually takes longer as law enforcement must first investigate the crash to locate the responsible party. This may involve reviewing surveillance footage, interviewing witnesses, examining physical evidence, and searching for the vehicle involved.

Other investigative steps that may delay the claims process include:

• Checking traffic cameras and footage from nearby businesses or homes
• Reviewing license plate reader data
• Examining paint fragments, broken lights, and vehicle debris left at the scene
• Comparing damage patterns with suspected vehicles
• Searching vehicle registration and repair records
• Contacting local body shops about vehicles with recent collision damage
• Reviewing 911 calls and public tips
• Coordinating with nearby law enforcement agencies
• Reconstructing the accident to determine the vehicle’s direction of travel
• Issuing public requests for information about the driver or vehicle

How Do Insurance Companies Handle Negotiations After a Car Accident?

During settlement negotiations, insurance companies review the available evidence to determine liability and confirm the extent of your damages. They examine police reports, medical records, witness statements, photographs, repair estimates, surveillance footage, and any other documentation related to the accident. Based on their evaluation, they calculate the average hit-and-run compensation amount and make a settlement offer.

However, the initial offer is frequently lower than the full value of your claim. It may not fully account for future medical treatment, lost earning capacity, pain and suffering, or other long-term losses. To counter these tactics, our lawyers prepare a comprehensive demand package and negotiate aggressively with the insurance company. If it refuses to offer a fair settlement, we are prepared to file a lawsuit and pursue the compensation you deserve.

Why Does Disputed Liability Delay a Hit-and-Run Settlement?

Disputed liability delays a claim because the insurance company will not release a payout until it determines who was legally responsible for the crash. If the available evidence does not clearly establish fault, the insurer may place the claim on hold while conducting a more detailed investigation.

During this time, the insurer may obtain additional evidence, interview witnesses, analyze vehicle damage, or hire accident reconstruction experts to determine how the collision occurred. If there are conflicting accounts of the crash, negotiations may not begin until these issues are resolved.

In some cases, insurers also use disputed liability to argue that you were partially or entirely responsible for the accident, allowing them to reduce or deny your claim. If the insurance company is delaying your claim by disputing liability, consult our Orlando hit-and-run accident lawyers at Todd Miner Law. Here’s how we counter these tactics:

• Conduct an independent investigation instead of relying solely on the insurer’s findings
• Secure surveillance footage before it is deleted or overwritten
• Locate and interview witnesses that the insurance company may have overlooked
• Challenge unsupported comparative negligence allegations with objective evidence
• Negotiate directly with insurance adjusters using evidence rather than assumptions

How Much Does a Hit-and-Run Lawyer Cost?

Most hit-and-run lawyers work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you do not pay any upfront attorney’s fees. Instead, your lawyer receives a percentage of the compensation recovered through a settlement or court verdict. If your case is unsuccessful, you generally do not owe an injury attorney’s fees.

However, you may still be responsible for certain car accident case-related expenses, such as:

• Court filing fees
• Expert witness fees
• Accident reconstruction costs
• Medical record and billing retrieval fees
• Deposition and court reporter costs
• Costs of obtaining police reports or other public records
• Postage, copying, and document preparation expenses
• Travel expenses related to the case, when necessary

Note: Whether you pay these costs if your case is unsuccessful depends on the terms of your contingency fee agreement with the law firm. Be sure to discuss this before signing a representation agreement.

What Happens If Your Hit-and-Run Claim Exceeds Policy Limits?

If your damages exceed the available insurance policy limits, recovering full compensation can become more challenging. Once the other party’s insurance company pays the maximum amount available under the policy, it has no obligation to pay anything further, even if your medical bills, lost wages, and other losses are significantly higher.

In these situations, your attorney will explore other sources of compensation that may be available, including:

• Your uninsured or underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) coverage
• Additional insurance policies that may apply
• Claims against other parties who contributed to the accident
• Personal assets of the at-fault driver, if they are identified and have collectible assets

If multiple sources of compensation are available, negotiations may take longer because each insurer will conduct its own investigation and determine its share of liability. Your attorney must also coordinate the claims, review policy language, and negotiate with each insurer to maximize your recovery.

What Steps Can You Take If Your Hit and Run Settlement Is Denied?

If an insurance company refuses to pay your hit-and-run claim, start by reviewing the denial letter to understand the insurer’s reasoning. The company may dispute coverage, liability, the connection between the crash and your injuries, or the value of your damages.

Then, gather evidence that directly addresses the insurer’s objections. This may include:

• Police and crash reports
• Witness statements
• Surveillance or traffic camera footage
• Medical records and bills
• Photos of your injuries and vehicle damage
• Proof of lost wages
• Uninsured motorist policy documents
• Communications with the insurance company

You may then submit a formal appeal or supplemental demand supported by the additional evidence. If the insurer continues to deny the claim, you can file a consumer complaint with the Florida Department of Financial Services through its Division of Consumer Services. The department may review the complaint, contact the insurer for a response, and assess whether the insurer complied with applicable insurance requirements. However, filing a complaint does not guarantee that the denial will be reversed or that compensation will be awarded.

Can Alternative Dispute Resolution Speed Up the Negotiation Process?

Yes, Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) can speed up the negotiation process. They provide a faster, less formal way to reduce disputes. Methods like mediation or arbitration allow parties to settle outside of court, reducing delays, attorney fees, and lengthy litigation, leading to quicker resolutions.

Here’s a detailed overview of two key methods of ADR that can speed up settlement negotiations:

Mediation

Mediation is a voluntary negotiation process in which a neutral third-party mediator helps both sides reach a mutually acceptable settlement. The mediator does not decide who is right or wrong and cannot force either party to accept an agreement.

Instead, they facilitate discussions, identify common ground, and encourage compromise. If both parties reach an agreement, the settlement is put in writing and becomes legally binding once signed. If mediation is unsuccessful, the claim can continue through litigation.

Arbitration

Arbitration is a more formal ADR process where an impartial arbitrator hears evidence from both sides before making a decision. Each party presents documents, witness testimony, and legal arguments. Depending on the terms of the insurance policy or the parties’ agreement, the arbitrator’s decision may be binding, meaning both sides must accept it.

It can also be non-binding, allowing either party to reject the decision and proceed with a lawsuit. Arbitration generally takes less time and costs less than a trial while still providing a structured way to resolve the dispute.

How Do Trial Delays Affect a Hit-and-Run Settlement?

Court backlogs, discovery disputes, depositions, expert scheduling, and pretrial motions may postpone the trial date. Until the case settles or a verdict is reached, you may continue waiting for compensation for medical bills, lost wages, and other damages.

Here are some other factors that can delay a trial:

• Limited court availability due to a heavy caseload
• Requests to postpone hearings by either party
• Delays in completing the discovery process
• Difficulty scheduling witness or expert testimony
• Additional medical examinations ordered during litigation
• Settlement conferences or court-ordered mediation before trial
• Disputes over the admissibility of evidence
• Pending motions that require a judge’s ruling
• Appeals of pretrial decisions

What Causes Delays in Hit-and-Run Car Accident Settlements?

Several factors, such as identifying the at-fault driver, multiple parties, insufficient evidence, or disputes over liability, can delay a settlement agreement. Insurance companies may also slow down the claim process to minimize payouts. Ongoing medical treatments or unresolved medical expenses can further prolong the settlement process.

Here are some other factors that may delay the hit-and-run car accident settlement:

• Delays in obtaining the official police report
• Difficulty locating witnesses or securing statements
• Missing or overwritten surveillance footage
• Disputes over uninsured motorist coverage
• Questions about whether the insurance policy was active
• Delays in receiving complete medical records
• Requests for independent medical examinations
• Disagreements over future medical expenses
• Disputes involving lost wages or reduced earning capacity
• Delays in hiring accident reconstruction or medical experts
• Arguments over vehicle repair costs or total-loss value
• Multiple insurance companies disputing responsibility
• Court backlogs after a lawsuit is filed
• Mediation or deposition scheduling conflicts

Todd Miner Law Can Speed Up Your Hit and Run Settlement — Get a Free Case Review Today!

After a hit-and-run accident, you may already be dealing with painful injuries, increasing medical bills, vehicle repairs, and missed work. In that situation, being unable to identify the driver or determine which insurance policy covers your losses can delay your settlement and increase your stress.

With strong Martindale-Hubbell ratings, our attorneys at Todd Miner Law gather strong evidence, file appropriate claims, and negotiate strategically to pursue fair compensation. We also have 30+ years of courtroom experience across Orlando and Central Florida. If an insurer unnecessarily delays payment or refuses to offer a fair settlement, we can pursue your case in court. Contact us or visit 915 Outer Rd, Orlando, FL, for a free consultation.

FAQs