What if Hertz Denied My Injury Claim?
If Hertz denies your accident claim, you should review the denial letter, gather all accident evidence, and file a formal internal appeal. During this time, you can use your personal insurance, such as credit card coverage or your own auto policy, to cover your losses.
With a recognition as a gold winner in Personal Injury Law Firm, our lawyers at Todd Miner Law prepare a detailed demand letter with supporting evidence, such as a police report and medical records. Then, we negotiate directly with Hertz to strengthen your case. However, if Hertz still refuses to offer fair compensation, we will help you pursue your case through litigation. Call 407-894-1480 for a free consultation.
What Should You Do If Hertz Denied Your Claim?
If Hertz denies your claim or charges you for damage you did not cause, gather all documents immediately, such as photos, the rental agreement, and the return records. Then, file a formal appeal to challenge the decision and present clear evidence to support your claim. You should also contact your credit card company if you used your credit card for the rental car. Beyond this, inform your auto insurance provider so they can review the case and help dispute the charges.
However, if liability is still disputed, file a complaint with the Florida Department of Financial Services to request an official review and seek a fair resolution. You can also file a personal injury lawsuit to seek compensation for your losses and hold the responsible party accountable. Here is how these steps strengthen your denied rental car accident case and protect your legal rights:
Gather Strong Evidence
Once you identify the reason for the denied claim, gather compelling evidence to support your case. For example, police reports, witness statements, and photos help prove fault. This evidence directly addresses issues such as disputed liability, policy limits, or claimed damages, which often lead to a denial in a rental car accident. In addition, you should also gather the following documents to strengthen your claim:
- Rental Agreement: Confirm you were an authorized driver listed on the rental agreement to avoid denial based on driver status.
- Repair Estimates and Damage Reports: Get written repair estimates and damage reports for the vehicle. These records show the actual cost of repairs and help challenge inflated or incorrect charges.
- Coverage Documents. Review your coverage details, including any damage waiver or liability protection, to ensure the insurance terms are correctly applied.
- Medical Records and Bills: Collect detailed medical records to clearly connect your injuries to the accident. These documents also show your total losses, including treatment costs and recovery expenses.
- Communication Logs and Records: Keep a record of all calls, emails, and letters with the insurer or rental company. This helps you track delays or unfair insurance company actions and supports your case.
File a Formal Appeal
To file a formal appeal for a denied rental car accident claim, you must review the denial letter. Then, identify the exact reason for denial, such as disputed liability or policy limits. After that, compare this reason with your rental agreement and insurance policy to determine whether the denial was incorrect or unfair to formally dispute the insurer’s decision.
Use Your Credit Card Coverage
You should review your card’s benefit guide to understand limits, rules, and deadlines for a rental car accident. Also, confirm that you paid for the full rental with your credit card and declined the rental company’s damage waiver. Then, prepare an appeal letter and quote the exact coverage terms from your policy to challenge the denial.
Inform Your Auto Insurance
If the rental company insurer denies your claim, inform your auto insurance provider right away to protect your rights. This legal action allows your insurer to review the case independently and challenge the denial with an unbiased assessment. Early reporting also helps your insurer address unfair conduct like bad faith under Florida Statutes § 624.155, which can support your claim for additional compensation. As a result, your insurer can initiate an early investigation and build a solid case to recover your losses.
File a Complaint for an Official Review
You can file a formal complaint with the Florida Department of Financial Services to request an official review of the denial. Submit your complaint online through the Division of Consumer Services with accurate details. For instance, include your policy number, claim number, and all supporting documents to present a clear and complete case. After that, the department reviews your complaint and requires the insurer to respond within 20 days. This step ensures a timely reassessment, strengthens your position during negotiation, and helps protect your legal rights.
Take Legal Action
If the insurer wrongfully denies your claim, you can file a lawsuit against the responsible party or the insurance company to recover your losses and hold them accountable. In some cases, parties resolve the case through the following legal options:
- Arbitration (a neutral third party reviews the case and gives a decision)
- Mediation (both sides negotiate a settlement with the help of a mediator)
However, to recover non-economic damages like pain and suffering, you must meet Florida’s serious injury threshold under Florida Statutes §627.737. This means your injury must involve permanent damage, significant scarring, disfigurement, or loss of an important bodily function.
Why Does Hertz Reject a Personal Injury Claim?
Hertz rejects personal injury claims due to violations of the rental terms, missing required coverage, or specific policy exclusions. For example, the company may deny the claim if the driver broke the agreement, such as driving under the influence or allowing an unlicensed person to operate the vehicle. Other than that, Hertz may refuse the claim if you did not purchase Liability Insurance Supplement (LIS) or if the accident happened beyond the covered rental period. These factors allow the company to argue that your claim does not qualify for compensation under the agreement.
In addition, Hertz may rely on the following reasons to deny the rental car accident case:
- Incorrect Details Provided: Giving false or incomplete information during the rental can lead to claim rejection.
- Restricted Use of Vehicle: Using the car for activities like racing, towing, or paid transport can void your claim.
- Delay in Reporting: Filing the claim after the allowed time period can result in denial.
What Tricks Do Adjusters Use to Deny Claims?
To deny a car accident case, adjusters ask for recorded statements and broad medical access to find inconsistencies in your statements. They also delay responses, misstate policy terms, or claim policy exclusions to justify denying or reducing your claim. In many cases, they shift blame onto you or point to small report errors to dispute liability and weaken your position.
At the same time, they may monitor your social media or question your injuries by linking them to pre-existing conditions. They can also deny coverage if the driver was not listed on the rental agreement or challenge how long you needed a rental car after the accident. As a result, these tactics reduce payouts and make it challenging for you to secure fair compensation.

What If Hertz Denies Your Claim Due to At-Fault Exclusion?
If Hertz denies your claim due to an at-fault exclusion, you may have to pay for the full cost of the vehicle, damages, and related fees. In this situation, review your rental agreement carefully to confirm the exact reason for the exclusion. You should also verify driver authorization and contact your personal auto insurance to check possible coverage under your policy. In addition, check other available coverage options that may help reduce your financial responsibility, such as:
- Credit Card Rental Coverage: Some credit cards offer Collision Damage Waiver (CDW) coverage if you pay for the rental with the card.
- Secondary Insurance Coverage: This coverage applies after your primary policy is exhausted to cover the remaining damages.
- Travel Insurance Plans: Certain travel policies include rental car damage or injury coverage.
- Third-Party Claim: You can file a claim under the other driver’s insurance or the other party’s insurance if they caused the crash.
- UM/UIM Coverage: Your own coverage may apply if the at-fault driver has limited coverage.
Beyond that, you can dispute the repair costs and “loss of use” fees (charges for the time the car stays unavailable) with the Hertz Subrogation team. However, before disputing these charges, you must consult with a qualified attorney to review your liability and protect your legal rights.
How Do Attorneys Prove Bad Faith Against Rental Companies?
At Todd Miner Law, we review your claim file to identify gaps in documentation, ignored evidence, or inconsistent decisions that led to the denial. After that, we subpoena internal records, such as emails, adjuster notes, and claim guidelines, to reveal the actual basis for the decision. We also examine communication history to show delays, missing responses, or misleading updates from rental car companies.
In addition, we use expert testimony to compare the company’s actions with accepted insurance practices. Once we build strong evidence, we present your case clearly and negotiate with the insurance company for fair compensation. If the insurer still refuses a fair outcome, we request mediation or file a bad-faith lawsuit to protect your rights.
Moreover, our attorneys take the following legal actions to strengthen your bad faith case and hold the rental company accountable:
Send a Demand Letter
Once you reach Maximum Medical Improvement (MMI), our lawyers gather evidence to prepare a detailed demand letter and address the insurer’s wrongful actions. This letter includes full documentation, such as medical records, lost wages, police reports, and witness statements, to show the actual value of your damages.
We also point out the other party’s unfair practices, such as denial without proper review, delayed responses, or misleading policy explanations. In addition, we demand a fair settlement amount and provide a clear deadline, usually 30 days, to require a proper response. If the insurer ignores the demand or refuses to act fairly, we file a Civil Remedy Notice to resolve the issue.
Insurance Adjuster Deposition
During the deposition, we question the adjuster under oath to uncover unfair claim handling and inconsistent statements. This process allows us to examine how the claim was reviewed and why the company denied or delayed it. We also compare their statements with internal records to identify contradictions. These findings help us prove that the rental company acted in bad faith rather than handling your claim fairly. Contact 407-894-1480 to protect your legal rights. Our team will get back to you within 24 hours.
Can Expert Witnesses Support Your Rental Car Injury Claim?
Yes, witness statements provide an independent account of the crash and strengthen your rental car injury claim. These statements help show that the other driver caused the crash and confirm key details like speed, signals, and vehicle position. Other than that, witnesses support your version of the crash events and help counter claims if the insurer denies your insurance claim. As a result, this evidence supports the fault and improves your chances of fair compensation.
Here are common expert witnesses who support your injury claim and prove liability:
Accident Reconstruction Specialists
Accident reconstruction specialists examine vehicle damage, road marks, and debris to determine how the accident occurred. They also create 3D simulations to present a clear visual explanation of the crash. This analysis helps challenge inaccurate reports or disputed fault claims under Florida traffic law.
Medical Experts
If you suffer serious injuries, specialists such as orthopedic surgeons or neurologists explain how the accident caused your condition. They also provide detailed medical records, diagnostic tests like X-rays or MRIs, and clear treatment plans to show the full extent of your rental car injury. In addition, their reports connect the crash’s impact to your symptoms and help establish injury severity.
Economic Loss Analysts
Beyond immediate medical bills, forensic economists calculate the full financial impact of your injuries to support your claim. For instance, they estimate future losses such as reduced earning capacity, lost wages, and long-term care costs. They also account for non-wage benefits and car rental costs, such as:
- Retirement Contributions: Loss of pension or future savings from your job
- Transport Expenses: Costs for travel, including medical visits or daily needs
- Employment Benefits: Loss of bonuses, health coverage, or other job-related income
Mental Health Specialists
Psychologists and psychiatrists assess conditions such as PTSD, anxiety, and depression and connect them directly to the crash. They provide detailed reports and testimony that explain how these conditions affect your daily life and recovery. Moreover, a study in the Journal of Clinical Medicine assessed 155 road traffic accident survivors and found significant psychological effects. After 1 month of the crash, researchers reported the following mental health findings:
- PTSD Symptoms: 32.3% of survivors reported post-traumatic stress
- Depression Symptoms: 17.4% showed signs of depression
- Anxiety Symptoms: 5.8% experienced anxiety after the accident
Biomechanical Engineers
During the investigation, biomechanical engineers analyze the forces involved in the crash to explain the cause of your injuries. They examine vehicle movement, seatbelt use, airbag deployment, and impact forces to link the collision to injuries such as whiplash. Their analysis supports injury causation and helps establish a clear link between the accident and your medical condition.
Product Safety Experts
If the rental agency failed to properly service the Hertz vehicle, such as bald tires, worn brakes, or missed recalls, it establishes a negligence maintenance claim. In such cases, product safety experts examine these defects in detail. They also review maintenance records and safety checks to identify ignored warnings or missed repairs. As a result, their findings help prove that poor vehicle condition caused the accident and support your rental car crash claim against the rental company.
Does Your Personal Auto Policy Apply After Claim Denial?
Yes, your personal auto policy provides coverage, even after a rental company denies a claim. For instance, collision and comprehensive coverage can pay for damage or theft of the Hertz rental car. On the other hand, liability coverage applies to injuries or property damage caused to others.
In addition, your own insurance, such as medical payments coverage, can help cover your medical expenses after an accident. However, you should review your collision and liability coverage to understand your personal accident insurance protection. You should also check your rental car coverage limits to avoid unexpected costs. Other than that, notify your insurance company early to report the claim and avoid missing important deadlines.
How Long Do You Have to Dispute a Denied Injury Case?
In Florida, you generally have up to 2 years from the accident date to file a personal injury lawsuit after a denial under Florida Statutes § 95.11. You can also file an internal appeal within 30 days to one year, based on your insurer’s rules. If the denial continues, you can request an external review within 4 months of the final decision.
Hertz Denied Your Injury Claim? We Can Help You Challenge It — Call Us Now!
If Hertz or its case administrator denies your injury claim, you may face delays in claim resolution, unclear responses, and difficulty getting key company records like inspection reports and damage assessments. You may also struggle to prove fault without legal support while paying medical bills on your own.
At Todd Miner Law, our lawyers gather key insurance information, including policy terms, claim files, and communication records, to examine your case value. We also subpoena internal records and evidence, which helps establish fault and strengthen your claim. Moreover, our team counters insurer tactics by challenging unfair denials and documenting delays. Call us at 407-894-1480 or visit our Orlando office to pursue fair compensation.
FAQs
Can A Denied Claim Affect My Credit Score?
Yes, a denied claim can decrease your credit score if you do not pay the damage charges. This happens when the rental company sends the unpaid balance to a debt collection agency. A denied claim also leads to rental blacklisting and limits your ability to rent vehicles in the future.
What If Hertz Delays My Claim Decision For Months?
You should send a certified letter to request a formal damage report and a clear update on your claim status. You can also dispute the charges and contact customer service to protect your rights. Beyond this, consult a personal injury attorney to ensure your claim is handled properly.
Can Hertz Deny Claims Due To The Delayed Crash Reporting?
Yes, Hertz can deny your claim if you delay reporting the accident. Under insurance law or rental policies, you should report the incident immediately. However, if you delay, Hertz may reject your insurance claim because late reporting makes it difficult to verify the accident details and damage accurately.
What If The Insurer Refuses To Provide Claim Documents?
You can send a formal demand letter to request your claim documents and create a record of refusal. You can also file a formal complaint with the Florida Department of Financial Services. If the insurer still refuses, you can file a lawsuit to address bad faith in the claims process.
Can A Rental Company Deny My Claim After Initially Approving It?
Yes, a rental company can deny your approved coverage during the final review if it finds disputed or inconsistent details. For example, an insurer may refuse payment if they identify missing documents or policy exclusions. They may also deny coverage if they detect fraud during the claims process.


